Black Friday: 50% off your first year of Plus or Pro, until Monday, November 30.See the prices

TQQQ strategies tested: 200-day rule vs buy and hold

Since TQQQ started trading in 2010, simply buying it and holding on has beaten every rule we tested. But those years were mostly good ones for tech stocks. In a simulated test back to 1986, buy and hold TQQQ fell 99.98% at its worst and grew less than plain QQQ. Two rules held up best over the full 40 years: a slow trend band and a volatility switch. No rule won every crash.

We tested 13 TQQQ strategies on real prices from 2010 and on simulated prices from 1986. This page shows the five most people ask about: buy and hold, the 200-day moving average, a trend band, 12-month momentum and a volatility switch. Each of the four rules is free to open on Tactfolio, with its full backtest. All figures are hypothetical and measured on November 10, 2026.

Key points#

  • Since 2010, buy and hold TQQQ grew about 39.9% a year. Every rule we tested grew less.
  • Since 1986, in simulated prices, buy and hold TQQQ grew 12.7% a year. Plain QQQ grew 14.6%. TQQQ lost 99.9% from 2000 to 2002.
  • The 200-day moving average rule cut losses in 2008 and 2022. It still lost 88% from 2000 to 2002, because prices kept crossing the average and it kept trading.
  • The trend band traded about once a year. Of the three trend rules, it lost the least from 2000 to 2002.
  • The volatility switch had the best overall record, but it lost 51% in 2008.
  • Every rule failed in at least one crash. Pick a rule for the crash you fear most, and expect it to fail in another.

Risk note. TQQQ aims for three times the Nasdaq 100’s move for one day only. It can lose most of its value in a fast fall. These are backtests on past and simulated prices, not predictions or advice.

What is TQQQ?#

TQQQ is ProShares UltraPro QQQ. It aims to return three times the daily move of the Nasdaq 100 index, before fees (ProShares). If the Nasdaq 100 rises 1% today, TQQQ aims to rise about 3%. If it falls 10%, TQQQ aims to fall about 30%.

The target resets every day. So over months and years, TQQQ’s return can be far from three times QQQ’s. Swings that go up and down eat into a leveraged fund. This is called volatility decay, and our guide to leveraged ETFs shows how it works with a two-day example. The SEC warns that results over longer periods “can differ significantly” from the daily target (SEC investor bulletin).

TQQQ costs more than QQQ, too. ProShares lists a yearly expense ratio of 0.94% before a fee waiver and 0.78% after it, checked November 11, 2026. For the head-to-head numbers, see QQQ vs TQQQ.

The five TQQQ strategies we tested#

Each rule holds TQQQ or Treasury bills, never both. For bills, the tests hold BIL, a fund of US Treasury bills that mature in one to three months. Bills pay a small, steady return, so they are the “safe” side of each rule.

Strategy (open it)Holds TQQQ whenChecks
Buy and holdAlwaysNever
200-day moving averageQQQ closes above its average of the last 200 daily closesEvery day
Trend bandSPY closes 4% above its 200-day average. It then holds until SPY closes 3% below itEvery day
12-month momentumQQQ’s return over the last 12 months beat T-bills’Last trading day of each month
Volatility switchQQQ’s daily swings over the last 21 trading days work out to less than 25% a yearEvery day

The rest of the time, each rule holds T-bills. Each name opens the rule on Tactfolio with its backtest, free and with no account. Buy and hold opens TQQQ’s fund page.

A moving average is the average closing price over a set number of days. Our moving average guide explains it. Volatility measures how much prices swing, as a yearly figure. For scale, QQQ swung about 21% a year on average since 2010.

Results since 2010: real TQQQ prices#

These tests use real fund prices from February 11, 2010 to November 10, 2026. Dividends are reinvested and each trade costs 0.05%.

StrategyYearly growthWorst fall$1 grew toSwitches a year
Buy and hold TQQQ39.9%81.7%$2750
Volatility switch37.2%51.3%$1994.8
12-month momentum35.1%69.9%$1540.7
Trend band31.3%55.7%$951.0
200-day moving average28.3%56.3%$656.1
Buy and hold QQQ (no leverage)18.8%35.1%$180

Worst fall is the biggest drop from a high point to a later low, also called the max drawdown. A switch is one move from TQQQ to bills or back.

Buy and hold won this period. The Nasdaq 100 rose most years after 2010, and its swings were mostly calm. Each rule sold during some dips that turned out to be short, then bought back higher. That cost growth. The rules did cut the worst fall. The volatility switch cut it from 81.7% to 51.3% and still grew 37.2% a year.

Results since 1986: simulated TQQQ#

TQQQ did not exist before 2010. To see how it might have done in the dot-com crash and in 2008, we used simulated prices. They model a 3x daily Nasdaq 100 fund back to 1986, from testfol.io’s simulated series. Our page on simulated history explains how Tactfolio builds and checks them. These tests run from October 15, 1986 to November 10, 2026 (the momentum rule from December 31, 1986, once it had a year of prices).

StrategyYearly growthWorst fallSwitches a year
Volatility switch28.4%70.5%5.4
Trend band27.0%80.7%0.8
200-day moving average19.3%95.2%6.7
12-month momentum19.2%97.1%1.2
Buy and hold QQQ (no leverage)14.6%83.0%0
Buy and hold TQQQ12.7%99.98%0

Over 40 years, buy and hold TQQQ finished last. One dollar grew to about $120. The same dollar in QQQ grew to about $231. The reason is the 2000 to 2002 crash. QQQ fell 83%. Simulated TQQQ fell 99.95%, from a high to its low. After a fall like that, a fund needs to grow about 2,000 times just to get back to even.

Scatter chart of six TQQQ strategies from 1986 to 2026. The volatility switch grew 28.4% a year with a 70.5% worst fall, and the trend band 27.0% with 80.7%. The 200-day rule and 12-month momentum grew about 19% but fell 95.2% and 97.1%. Buy and hold TQQQ grew only 12.7% a year and fell 99.98%, worse than plain QQQ at 14.6% and 83.0%.
Over 40 years, buy and hold TQQQ ends up bottom right: the least growth and the deepest fall. The volatility switch and the trend band held up best, but each still fell more than 70% at its worst.

The big yearly numbers for the rules come from a model. A real fund can trail its model because of fees, borrowing costs and trading. Treat this table as a rough guide to which rules held up, not as the return you would have earned.

How each TQQQ strategy did in the big crashes#

Each window starts at the last close of the year before. The 2000 to 2002 and 2008 windows use simulated prices. The 2020 and 2022 windows use real prices.

Strategy2000 to 2002200820202022
Buy and hold TQQQminus 99.9%minus 88.5%+109.9%minus 79.1%
Buy and hold QQQminus 73.3%minus 41.8%+48.3%minus 32.6%
200-day moving averageminus 88.3%minus 43.8%+104.8%minus 43.1%
Trend bandminus 65.5%+1.5%+48.1%minus 45.0%
12-month momentumminus 87.7%minus 51.8%+110.1%minus 55.5%
Volatility switch+0.5%minus 51.3%+26.9%minus 38.9%
Grid of returns for six TQQQ strategies in four crashes. No row is green in every column. Buy and hold TQQQ lost 99.9% in 2000 to 2002, 88.5% in 2008 and 79.1% in 2022. The volatility switch gained 0.5% in 2000 to 2002 but lost 51.3% in 2008. The trend band gained 1.5% in 2008 but lost 45.0% in 2022.
No rule stayed out of the red in every crash. Pick a rule for the crash you fear most, and expect it to fail in another.

No rule won every column. Here is what happened in each crash.

  • 2000 to 2002. The Nasdaq 100 kept bouncing up through its 200-day average and then falling again. The 200-day rule bought each bounce and sold each drop, about 8 switches a year, and lost 88%. The volatility switch spent nearly all of it in bills, because swings stayed big.
  • 2008. The fall was slower at first. The trend band had already moved to bills in late 2007 and stayed there. The volatility switch flipped in and out 20 times as swings hovered near its 25% line, and lost 51%.
  • 2020. The COVID crash was fast. No daily rule could get out before the first big drops. The 200-day rule sold after the fall and bought back in time for most of the rebound. The volatility switch stayed in bills while swings stayed big, so it missed most of the rebound.
  • 2022. Prices fell all year in waves. Every TQQQ rule lost at least 38.9%, and the 200-day rule switched 10 times.

Why the 200-day rule still lost 95%#

The 200-day moving average is the best-known rule for leveraged funds. Michael Gayed and Charles Bilello tested it on the S&P 500 in their 2016 paper “Leverage for the Long Run” (SSRN). Their idea: leveraged funds do best in calm, rising markets, and those mostly happen above the 200-day average. Tactfolio tracks their S&P 500 version as the Leverage Rotation Strategy, and the unleveraged rule as the 200-day moving average strategy.

The rule works well in a long, steady fall, like 2008. It works badly when prices chop around the average. Each false signal sells low and buys back higher. With 3x leverage, each of those small losses is three times as big. That is how the rule lost 88% from 2000 to 2002 and 95% at its worst over 40 years.

Trading costs add up, too. At 0.40% per trade instead of 0.05%, the 200-day rule’s simulated yearly growth fell from 19.3% to 13.9%. The trend band, which traded far less, only fell from 27.0% to 26.3%.

Why the trend band traded less#

The trend band waits for a cushion. It buys only when SPY closes 4% above its 200-day average. It sells only when SPY closes 3% below it. Small wiggles around the average do nothing. Traders on the r/LETFs forum share this rule, and we tested a simple version of it.

It also watches SPY, the S&P 500, instead of QQQ. The S&P 500 swings less than the Nasdaq 100, so it gives fewer false signals. The same band on QQQ switched about twice as often in the simulated test and lost 90.7% at its worst.

The cost of waiting is that the band reacts late. In 2022 it sold after much of the fall and lost 45%.

Why the volatility switch works, and when it fails#

Volatility decay grows with the square of the swings. Double the swings, and the drag on a 3x fund is about four times as big. Say you expect the Nasdaq 100 to beat cash by about 9% a year, a cautious guess below its past. Then the drag cancels a 3x fund’s whole edge over cash once QQQ swings about 25% a year or more. So we picked 25% from that math, before running any test.

Research on stocks points the same way. Alan Moreira and Tyler Muir found that cutting stock exposure when volatility is high improved risk-adjusted returns (Volatility-Managed Portfolios). Tactfolio’s volatility-managed portfolio follows their paper.

The switch has a weak spot. When swings sit right around 25%, it flips in and out, as it did 20 times in 2008. And after a crash, swings stay big for weeks, so it buys back late.

Why 12-month momentum was too slow for TQQQ#

Momentum means holding what has gone up. The 12-month rule is the “absolute momentum” half of Gary Antonacci’s dual momentum (SSRN), which Tactfolio tracks as Dual Momentum. It checks once a month and trades about once a year.

That works for a normal stock fund. At 3x, it is too slow. By the time a whole year of returns turns negative, TQQQ may have already lost half its value. The momentum rule held TQQQ through the whole 2020 crash and lost 87.7% from 2000 to 2002. Our momentum strategy guide covers the idea in more detail.

Other versions we tested#

We tested seven more versions to answer common questions. Same dates, same costs.

VersionSince 2010: growth, worst fallSince 1986 (simulated): growth, worst fall
200-day rule with QLD (2x) instead of TQQQ21.1%, 43.1%17.3%, 84.5%
200-day rule with QQQ (no leverage)12.4%, 24.4%12.0%, 56.6%
200-day rule, holding QQQ instead of bills below the line34.7%, 58.8%21.3%, 97.8%
200-day rule using SPY’s average instead of QQQ’s33.0%, 59.0%24.6%, 95.7%
Trend band using QQQ instead of SPY27.9%, 66.0%18.5%, 90.7%
Both the 200-day rule and the volatility switch must agree27.7%, 52.0%18.2%, 69.0%
Buy and hold QLD (2x)31.3%, 63.7%17.1%, 98.9%

A few lessons stand out. Holding QQQ instead of bills below the line grew more but fell 97.8% in the long test, because QQQ also crashed. Using 2x leverage instead of 3x cut the worst fall but also the growth. Making the 200-day rule and the volatility switch agree cut the 200-day rule’s worst fall from 95.2% to 69.0%, but it grew far less than the volatility switch alone.

How we tested#

  • Engine. Tactfolio’s backtester, the same one the builder uses. Signals and trades use the same day’s closing price, with a 0.05% cost per trade. Dividends are reinvested. Our methodology page has the details.
  • Prices. Real TQQQ prices from February 11, 2010. Before that, simulated TQQQ and QQQ from testfol.io. T-bills before BIL’s 2007 launch follow the 13-week Treasury bill rate.
  • No tuning. We set every rule and number before the first test: the 200-day average, the 4% and 3% band, the 12-month window and the 25% line. We did not try other numbers to find the best result.
  • Limits. Real trading would fill at slightly different prices. Simulated prices are a model. Taxes are not included. A backtest shows how a rule behaved in the past, not what it will do next.

Taxes and accounts#

Every switch from TQQQ to bills is a sale. In a taxable US account, a sale at a gain can mean a tax bill. Gains on shares held one year or less are taxed at higher, short-term rates (IRS Topic 409). A rule that switches six times a year makes almost every gain short term. That is one reason many people who follow these rules use a tax-advantaged account, like the ones in our IRA vs 401(k) guide.

Try these TQQQ strategies on Tactfolio#

Each rule above is published free by the Tactfolio Research Lab. Open one to read its rules, step by step, and see its backtest, with no account needed. The page covers a different period than the tables here, so its numbers will not match exactly. Its live record started on the day it was published.

To copy a rule and change it, for example to try a 150-day average or swap TQQQ for UPRO, you need a paid plan. To see what 3x exposure means in dollars first, try the leverage calculator.

Here is the 200-day rule as the builder shows it:

Tactfolio TQQQ 200-Day Trend
IfAll of
Then
TQQQ
Else
BIL

And the volatility switch, where 0.25 means 25% a year:

Tactfolio TQQQ Volatility Switch
IfAll of
Then
TQQQ
Else
BIL

Common questions#

What is the best TQQQ strategy?#

No rule won every test. Over 40 years of simulated prices, the volatility switch and the trend band held up best. Since 2010, buy and hold beat every rule. Each rule failed in at least one crash, so the best choice depends on which crash you want to survive.

Is TQQQ a good long-term investment?#

Since 2010 it has grown about 39.9% a year, with a worst fall of 81.7%. In simulated prices back to 1986, it grew less than QQQ and lost 99.95% in the dot-com crash. TQQQ seeks its 3x target for one day at a time. FINRA says daily-reset funds “typically are unsuitable for retail investors who plan to hold them for longer than one trading session” (FINRA Notice 09-31).

Does the 200-day moving average work with TQQQ?#

It helped in slow crashes like 2008, when it lost 43.8% while TQQQ lost 88.5%. It did badly in choppy markets. From 2000 to 2002 it lost 88%, and its worst fall over 40 years was 95%. A band around the average, like the trend band that buys 4% above and sells 3% below, cut the trading a lot.

Can TQQQ go to zero?#

It would if the Nasdaq 100 fell about 33% in one day, which it never has. A long slide can still wipe out most of the value. Real TQQQ fell 81.7% from late 2021 to late 2022. Simulated TQQQ fell 99.95% from 2000 to 2002.

Should the 200-day signal use QQQ or SPY?#

In our tests, SPY’s average gave higher growth than QQQ’s for the plain 200-day rule, with a similar worst fall. For the 4% and 3% band, SPY was better on both: 27.0% a year and an 80.7% worst fall in simulation, against 18.5% and 90.7% with QQQ. The S&P 500 swings less, so it sends fewer false signals.

Is QLD better than TQQQ for a trend rule?#

QLD seeks two times the Nasdaq 100’s daily move. With the 200-day rule, QLD fell less (84.5% at worst in simulation, against 95.2% for TQQQ) but grew less too. Since 2010, TQQQ with the rule grew 28.3% a year and QLD 21.1%.

How did TQQQ do in 2008?#

TQQQ did not exist yet. Simulated TQQQ lost 88.5% in 2008. The trend band was already in T-bills and ended the year up 1.5%. The 200-day rule lost 43.8%.

Sources