Classic tactical asset allocation strategies
Well-known rules from published research, built on Tactfolio from the authors’ own papers and tested on daily ETF prices. Each one is live: open it, inspect every rule, or copy it and change it. The premium ones open their live rules with Plus and Pro.
Canary and breadth momentum
Keller and Keuning’s family: a few warning assets, or how many assets are falling, decide how defensive to be.
Hybrid Asset Allocation (HAA)
PremiumWouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2023
Keller and Keuning’s HAA uses a TIP canary to sidestep inflation shocks.
- 10.0% a year since 2008
- −15% worst drawdown
- 0.91 Sharpe ratio
HAA Simple: Hybrid Asset Allocation with one asset
PremiumWouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2023
The single-asset HAA: hold the S&P 500 while TIP and SPY momentum are positive, else bonds or bills.
- 11.7% a year since 2008
- −20% worst drawdown
- 0.98 Sharpe ratio
Bold Asset Allocation (BAA)
Wouter Keller, 2022
Wouter Keller’s BAA pairs a fast canary with slow momentum picks and a rule for rising rates.
- 8.1% a year since 2008
- −14% worst drawdown
- 0.84 Sharpe ratio
Vigilant Asset Allocation (VAA)
Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2017
Keller and Keuning’s VAA-G4 uses breadth momentum to hold one of four assets or move to bonds.
- 9.8% a year since 2004
- −21% worst drawdown
- 0.76 Sharpe ratio
Defensive Asset Allocation (DAA)
Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2018
Keller and Keuning’s DAA watches two canary assets to decide how defensive to be.
- 8.1% a year since 2008
- −20% worst drawdown
- 0.79 Sharpe ratio
Protective Asset Allocation (PAA)
Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2016
Keller and Keuning’s PAA moves into Treasuries step by step as market breadth weakens.
- 6.7% a year since 2008
- −14% worst drawdown
- 0.80 Sharpe ratio
Vigilant Asset Allocation G12 (VAA-G12)
Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2017
Keller and Keuning’s twelve-asset VAA steps into bonds as more assets show negative momentum.
- 7.5% a year since 2008
- −30% worst drawdown
- 0.67 Sharpe ratio
Bold Asset Allocation G4 (BAA aggressive)
Wouter Keller, 2022
Wouter Keller’s aggressive BAA holds the strongest of QQQ, VWO, VEA, and BND while its canaries are healthy.
- 9.3% a year since 2008
- −20% worst drawdown
- 0.75 Sharpe ratio
HAA 60/40 (NLX Finance’s Hybrid Asset Allocation variant)
PremiumNicolas Lequeux (NLX Finance), 2024
HAA Simple’s TIPS canary with a 60/40 stock and bond mix when risk is on.
- 8.2% a year since 2008
- −10% worst drawdown
- 1.10 Sharpe ratio
Kipnis Defensive Adaptive Asset Allocation (KDA)
Ilya Kipnis, 2019
Two canaries scale risk; momentum picks up to five of ten asset classes.
- 6.7% a year since 2008
- −18% worst drawdown
- 0.70 Sharpe ratio
Momentum rotation
Hold whichever assets have risen most, often only while they also beat cash.
Adaptive Asset Allocation (AAA)
Adam Butler, Michael Philbrick, Rodrigo Gordillo, and David Varadi, 2012
Butler, Philbrick, Gordillo, and Varadi’s AAA: top five of ten asset classes by momentum, weighted by inverse volatility.
- 9.7% a year since 2007
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.88 Sharpe ratio
Dual Momentum: Antonacci’s Global Equities Momentum (GEM)
Gary Antonacci, 2014
Gary Antonacci’s dual momentum picks US stocks, foreign stocks, or bonds each month by 12-month return.
- 8.6% a year since 2008
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.59 Sharpe ratio
Composite Dual Momentum
Gary Antonacci, 2012
Antonacci’s diversified dual momentum: four modules for stocks, credit, REITs, and stress assets.
- 5.4% a year since 2008
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.61 Sharpe ratio
GTAA Aggressive 3 (Faber GTAA AGG3)
Mebane Faber, 2013
Faber’s GTAA AGG3: the top 3 of 13 asset classes by momentum, each above its 10-month average.
- 7.7% a year since 2008
- −19% worst drawdown
- 0.59 Sharpe ratio
GTAA Aggressive 6 (Faber GTAA AGG6)
Mebane Faber, 2013
Faber’s GTAA AGG6: the top 6 of 13 asset classes by momentum, each above its 10-month average.
- 9.0% a year since 2008
- −17% worst drawdown
- 0.79 Sharpe ratio
Ivy Portfolio rotation (Faber’s relative strength model)
Mebane Faber and Eric Richardson, 2009
The Ivy Portfolio’s momentum rotation: top 3 of 5 asset classes, each above its 10-month average.
- 7.7% a year since 2007
- −21% worst drawdown
- 0.72 Sharpe ratio
Faber sector rotation (the three strongest US sectors)
Mebane Faber, 2010
Faber’s sector rotation holds the 3 strongest US sectors and moves to bills below the S&P 500’s 10-month average.
- 7.7% a year since 2007
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.61 Sharpe ratio
Mama Bear Portfolio (Muscular Portfolios)
Brian Livingston, 2018
Brian Livingston’s Mama Bear holds the top three of nine funds, cash included, by five-month return.
- 9.3% a year since 2007
- −25% worst drawdown
- 0.73 Sharpe ratio
Papa Bear Portfolio (Muscular Portfolios)
Brian Livingston, 2018
Brian Livingston’s Papa Bear holds the top three of thirteen asset-class funds by blended momentum.
- 8.6% a year since 2007
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.64 Sharpe ratio
US Cross-Asset Momentum (stock and Treasury timing)
Aleksi Pitkäjärvi, Matti Suominen, and Lauri Vaittinen, 2016
Stocks when stocks and Treasuries beat bills, Treasuries when only they do, else cash.
- 6.5% a year since 2008
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.57 Sharpe ratio
Defense First (Carlson’s defensive tactical model)
PremiumThomas D. Carlson, 2025
Four defensive assets at 40/30/20/10 by momentum, with stocks taking any slot that trails bills.
- 9.8% a year since 2008
- −13% worst drawdown
- 0.98 Sharpe ratio
Paired Switching (quarterly SPY and TLT rotation)
Akhilesh Maewal and Joel R. Bock, 2011
Each quarter, hold whichever of the S&P 500 and long Treasuries returned more.
- 7.6% a year since 2002
- −36% worst drawdown
- 0.54 Sharpe ratio
Quint Switching Filtered (Lewis Glenn’s QSF)
Lewis A. Glenn, 2018
The strongest of five markets by 3-month return if all five are up, else Treasuries.
- 8.2% a year since 2003
- −27% worst drawdown
- 0.75 Sharpe ratio
Accelerating Dual Momentum (ADM)
Engineered Portfolio (Steve Hanly), 2018
Monthly rotation between the S&P 500, international small caps, and long Treasuries.
- 11.1% a year since 2008
- −38% worst drawdown
- 0.73 Sharpe ratio
Diversified Dual Momentum (Newfound Research)
Corey Hoffstein (Newfound Research), 2019
Seven copies of Dual Momentum GEM with 6- to 12-month lookbacks.
- 7.6% a year since 2008
- −31% worst drawdown
- 0.58 Sharpe ratio
Paul Novell's Tactical Bond Strategy
Paul Novell, 2014
Holds the three strongest of nine bond ETFs by six-month return, or cash.
- 3.0% a year since 2013
- −11% worst drawdown
- 0.53 Sharpe ratio
Beta Rotation Strategy (utilities vs. the market)
Charles Bilello and Michael Gayed, 2014
Bilello and Gayed’s weekly switch between utilities (XLU) and the S&P 500 on four-week strength.
- 6.8% a year since 1999
- −52% worst drawdown
- 0.45 Sharpe ratio
Tactical Risk Rotation (TRRS)
Michael Gayed and Charles Bilello, 2014
Gayed and Bilello’s TRRS holds stocks when 10-year Treasuries beat 30-year ones, else Treasuries.
- 8.2% a year since 2002
- −36% worst drawdown
- 0.67 Sharpe ratio
Trend following and timing
Hold an asset while its trend, its distance from a recent high, or its volatility says conditions are good, and step aside otherwise.
Faber’s 10-month moving average timing model
Mebane Faber, 2007
Mebane Faber’s trend rule: hold the S&P 500 above its 10-month average, T-bills below.
- 7.7% a year since 2007
- −25% worst drawdown
- 0.64 Sharpe ratio
12-Month High Switch (Meb Faber)
Mebane Faber, 2020
Hold five asset classes only while within 5% of their 12-month high, else 10-year Treasuries.
- 6.4% a year since 2007
- −18% worst drawdown
- 0.75 Sharpe ratio
Gold Cross-Asset Momentum (gold and Treasury rule)
Cyril Dujava (Quantpedia), 2026
Hold gold only while gold and Treasuries both rose over 12 months, else cash.
- 8.0% a year since 2007
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.60 Sharpe ratio
Trending Fast and Slow (volatility-switched momentum)
Eddie Cheng, Nazar Kostyuchyk, Wai Lee, Pai Liu, and Chenfei Ma, 2022
Volatility picks a 1- or 12-month S&P 500 trend; stocks in an uptrend, cash otherwise.
- 7.9% a year since 2007
- −28% worst drawdown
- 0.64 Sharpe ratio
Leverage Rotation Strategy (UPRO above the 200-day average)
PremiumMichael Gayed and Charles Bilello, 2016
Gayed and Bilello’s LRS holds 3x S&P 500 (UPRO) above the 200-day average and T-bills below.
- 23.0% a year since 2009
- −52% worst drawdown
- 0.76 Sharpe ratio
Leverage Rotation Strategy 2x (LRS with SSO)
PremiumMichael Gayed and Charles Bilello, 2016
The 2x Leverage Rotation Strategy: SSO above the S&P 500’s 200-day average, T-bills below.
- 12.5% a year since 2007
- −40% worst drawdown
- 0.62 Sharpe ratio
200-Day Moving Average Strategy (S&P 500)
Jeremy Siegel, 1994; Michael Gayed and Charles Bilello, 2016
Hold the S&P 500 above its 200-day moving average and T-bills below, checked daily.
- 7.9% a year since 2007
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.70 Sharpe ratio
Golden Cross Strategy (50-day and 200-day moving averages)
Technical analysis tradition
Hold the S&P 500 after a golden cross, T-bills after a death cross of its 50- and 200-day averages.
- 8.6% a year since 2007
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.66 Sharpe ratio
Volatility-Managed Portfolio (Moreira and Muir)
Alan Moreira and Tyler Muir, 2017
Moreira and Muir’s rule cuts S&P 500 exposure after volatile months and holds T-bills for the rest.
- 7.2% a year since 2007
- −17% worst drawdown
- 0.74 Sharpe ratio
Economic signals
Unemployment, the yield curve, and other economic data, each used from the day it was published, decide when to own stocks.
Growth-Trend Timing (Philosophical Economics’ GTT)
PremiumJesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016
Leave the S&P 500 only when growth data turn negative and the trend breaks.
- 11.9% a year since 2007
- −22% worst drawdown
- 0.83 Sharpe ratio
Growth-Trend Timing with unemployment (GTT-UE)
PremiumJesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016
Leave the S&P 500 only when unemployment is rising and the trend breaks.
- 10.7% a year since 2007
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.72 Sharpe ratio
Growth-Trend Timing with job growth
PremiumJesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016
Leave the S&P 500 only when jobs per worker fall and the trend breaks.
- 11.9% a year since 2007
- −34% worst drawdown
- 0.77 Sharpe ratio
Growth-Trend Timing with housing starts and income
Jesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016
Leave the S&P 500 only when housing starts or real income weaken and the trend breaks.
- 8.0% a year since 2007
- −25% worst drawdown
- 0.66 Sharpe ratio
Lethargic Asset Allocation (Keller’s LAA)
PremiumWouter J. Keller, 2019
Value stocks, gold, and Treasuries, with a Nasdaq-100 quarter timed by unemployment and trend.
- 9.5% a year since 2004
- −20% worst drawdown
- 0.97 Sharpe ratio
Resilient Asset Allocation (Keller’s RAA)
Wouter J. Keller, 2020
Five assets at 20% each, moving to Treasuries when unemployment rises and canaries weaken.
- 8.1% a year since 2008
- −26% worst drawdown
- 0.85 Sharpe ratio
Bond UI1 (Paul Novell’s unemployment bond strategy)
Paul Novell, 2019
Credit bonds while unemployment is stable, Treasuries when it rises.
- 1.0% a year since 2013
- −26% worst drawdown
- 0.19 Sharpe ratio
TrendYCMacro (Quantpedia’s market timing strategy)
Ladislav Ďurian and Radovan Vojtko (Quantpedia), 2023
S&P 500 timing from price trend, the yield curve, and real economic growth.
- 10.0% a year since 2008
- −23% worst drawdown
- 0.82 Sharpe ratio
Pragmatic Asset Allocation (Quantpedia’s PAA)
PremiumRadovan Vojtko and Juliána Javorská (Quantpedia), 2024
The two strongest stock markets in an uptrend, hedged when the yield curve inverts.
- 9.5% a year since 2009
- −24% worst drawdown
- 0.70 Sharpe ratio
Inflation Compass (Varadi’s growth and inflation model)
PremiumDavid Varadi, 2026
Energy, technology, utilities, or staples by growth trend and breakeven inflation.
- 20.3% a year since 2003
- −24% worst drawdown
- 1.09 Sharpe ratio
Diversified tactical portfolios
Fixed mixes of asset classes where each slice is switched to cash when its own trend or momentum fails.
Global Tactical Asset Allocation (GTAA 5)
Mebane Faber, 2007
Mebane Faber’s GTAA holds five asset classes, each while above its 10-month average.
- 4.9% a year since 2007
- −15% worst drawdown
- 0.63 Sharpe ratio
GTAA 13: Faber’s 13-asset tactical allocation
Mebane Faber, 2013
Faber’s GTAA 13 times thirteen asset classes at fixed weights with a 10-month average.
- 5.5% a year since 2008
- −12% worst drawdown
- 0.71 Sharpe ratio
Trinity Portfolio (Meb Faber)
Mebane Faber, 2016
Meb Faber’s Trinity Portfolio: half global buy-and-hold, half trend-following momentum.
- 7.0% a year since 2008
- −18% worst drawdown
- 0.81 Sharpe ratio
US Risk Parity Trend-Following (The Trend is Our Friend)
Andrew Clare, James Seaton, Peter N. Smith, and Stephen Thomas, 2016
Five US asset classes sized by volatility, each moved to cash below its 10-month average.
- 4.0% a year since 2007
- −11% worst drawdown
- 0.69 Sharpe ratio
Global Risk Parity Trend-Following (Clare et al.)
Andrew Clare, James Seaton, Peter N. Smith, and Stephen Thomas, 2016
Five global asset classes sized by volatility, each moved to cash below its 10-month average.
- 2.8% a year since 2013
- −12% worst drawdown
- 0.48 Sharpe ratio
Robust Asset Allocation Balanced (Alpha Architect RAA)
Wesley Gray (Alpha Architect), 2014
Wesley Gray's 40/40/20 mix with two trend rules per asset class.
- 4.8% a year since 2015
- −16% worst drawdown
- 0.66 Sharpe ratio
Robust Asset Allocation Aggressive (Alpha Architect RAA)
Wesley Gray (Alpha Architect), 2014
Wesley Gray's 80% stock RAA flavor with two trend rules per asset class.
- 5.5% a year since 2015
- −25% worst drawdown
- 0.55 Sharpe ratio
Tactical Permanent Portfolio (GestaltU / ReSolve)
Adam Butler, Michael Philbrick, and Rodrigo Gordillo, 2012
Stocks, Treasuries, and gold held only above their 200-day average, weighted by inverse volatility.
- 6.9% a year since 2007
- −11% worst drawdown
- 1.05 Sharpe ratio
Three-Way Model (Ned Davis Research)
Ned Davis Research, 2015
Stocks, long Treasuries, and gold, each held while its 3-month average tops its 10-month.
- 8.8% a year since 2007
- −23% worst drawdown
- 0.76 Sharpe ratio
Static portfolios
Fixed weights, rebalanced on a schedule. No signals at all; they are the baselines tactical strategies have to beat.
Baby Bear Portfolio (Muscular Portfolios)
Brian Livingston, 2018
Brian Livingston’s Baby Bear: 50% US stocks, 50% US bonds, rebalanced yearly on drift.
- 7.4% a year since 2003
- −29% worst drawdown
- 0.79 Sharpe ratio
All Weather Portfolio (Ray Dalio’s All Seasons)
Ray Dalio and Tony Robbins, 2014
Ray Dalio’s All Weather mix via Tony Robbins: 30% stocks, 55% Treasuries, 15% gold and commodities.
- 6.5% a year since 2006
- −24% worst drawdown
- 0.81 Sharpe ratio
Harry Browne’s Permanent Portfolio
Harry Browne, 1999
Harry Browne’s Permanent Portfolio: 25% each in stocks, long Treasuries, gold, and cash.
- 7.1% a year since 2007
- −18% worst drawdown
- 0.90 Sharpe ratio
Golden Butterfly Portfolio
Tyler (Portfolio Charts), 2015
The Golden Butterfly: 20% each in stocks, small-cap value, long and short Treasuries, and gold.
- 7.7% a year since 2004
- −20% worst drawdown
- 0.90 Sharpe ratio
Ivy Portfolio (Faber and Richardson, buy and hold)
Mebane Faber and Eric Richardson, 2009
The Ivy Portfolio: a fifth each in US and foreign stocks, Treasuries, REITs, and commodities.
- 5.7% a year since 2006
- −49% worst drawdown
- 0.46 Sharpe ratio
60/40 Portfolio (classic stocks and bonds)
Traditional balanced funds
The classic 60/40: 60% S&P 500 and 40% intermediate Treasuries, the yardstick for every classic.
- 8.2% a year since 2002
- −33% worst drawdown
- 0.80 Sharpe ratio
Three-Fund Portfolio (Taylor Larimore, Bogleheads)
Taylor Larimore, 2018
Taylor Larimore’s Three-Fund Portfolio: US stocks, world stocks, and bonds in three index funds.
- 10.0% a year since 2011
- −28% worst drawdown
- 0.77 Sharpe ratio
How we build and present the classics
We build every published strategy our builder can express from its author's own paper, book, or post, and name every place where our version differs. Each one is tested on real ETF prices, with simulated history for the years before the funds existed. The ETF screener lists every fund the classics hold, with its fee, returns and worst drop.
We show the results as they are. Some famous strategies, including Faber's five-asset GTAA and Antonacci's Dual Momentum, trailed a plain 60/40 stock and bond mix on risk-adjusted return over the ETF era, and their pages say so. A classic being listed here is not a recommendation.
Our classic strategies scorecard puts them side by side: how each one did against the S&P 500 once its rules were published, updated after every close.
Strategies we can't build yet
Some well-known strategies need something our builder doesn't have. We would rather leave them out than publish a version that only looks like the original.
- Other economic signals: Faber's Tactical Yield and Predicting Bond Returns compare a series with its own history (a percentile to date, a rolling z-score); Dividend & Growth Allocation, the Global Growth Cycle, and SPF Recession Probability need dividend yields, OECD leading indicators, or survey forecasts; Paul Novell's SPY-COMP and Bond-COMP use private rules; and the Excess Earnings Yield models need earnings data.
- Portfolio optimization or correlation: Classical, Elastic, and Flexible Asset Allocation, Generalized Protective Momentum, the Minimum Correlation Portfolio, the Efficiente index, and maximum diversification, equal risk contribution, and maximum Sharpe portfolios.
- Calendar rules: Sell in May and annual seasonality strategies.
- Other signals: Varadi's Percentile Channels, Dick Stoken's Active Combined Asset, Momentum Turning Points, and Momentum Based Balancing.
- Unpublished rules: Risk Managed Momentum, Optimum3, All-Weather Quad Momentum, and Antonacci's Dual Momentum Sector Rotation.