Black Friday: 50% off your first year of Plus or Pro, until Monday, November 30.See the prices

Papa Bear Portfolio (Muscular Portfolios)

Brian Livingston's Papa Bear from Muscular Portfolios, adapted from Mebane Faber's momentum rotation. Each month it ranks thirteen funds (US value and growth stocks in large and small sizes, developed and emerging stocks, real estate, commodities, gold, and four kinds of bonds) by the average of their 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month returns (the book averages 3, 6, and 12) and holds the top three in equal parts. It has no cash rule and is always invested.

Designed by Brian Livingston, 2018. Implemented and tracked by Tactfolio.

1×2×3×5×20072011201520192023
Growth of $1, log scale. Strategy SPY. Hypothetical results on daily ETF prices with trading costs, through Nov 2026.
Feb 2007 to Nov 2026StrategySPY
Annual return (CAGR)8.6%10.5%
Worst drawdown−22.3%−55.2%
Sharpe ratio0.640.61
Volatility14.6%19.6%
Annual return since publication (Feb 2018)7.8%13.1%

The Papa Bear Portfolio is a monthly momentum strategy from Brian Livingston’s 2018 book Muscular Portfolios, the largest of its three portfolios. Once a month it ranks thirteen funds covering stocks, real estate, commodities, gold, and bonds by their average return over the past several months. It holds the top three in equal parts.

Key points#

  • Papa Bear checks once a month and holds three of thirteen funds, a third each.
  • It scores each fund by an average of its 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month returns.
  • It has no cash fund, so its defense comes from the bond funds in the list.
  • Its worst drawdown was about 22% since early 2007, against 55% for the S&P 500.
  • It lagged badly in calm, rising years, trailing the S&P 500 by 19 to 24 percentage points in 2019 and 2023.

What is the Papa Bear Portfolio?#

The Papa Bear Portfolio is a rotation that uses momentum across many kinds of assets. Momentum means that assets that have risen lately tend to keep rising for a while.

Livingston adapted it from the rotation in Mebane Faber’s 2013 update of his tactical allocation paper. That paper ranks asset classes by an average of several lookback periods. A lookback is the stretch of past time a rule measures.

Averaging short and long periods favors trends that have lasted, not a single strong month. Papa Bear is one of the momentum models in our library of classic strategies.

How does Papa Bear protect against losses?#

Papa Bear’s defense comes from the four bond funds in its list. When stocks and commodities fall, Treasuries and other bonds tend to rise to the top of the ranking.

Unlike Mama Bear, it has no cash fund and no trend filter. Livingston’s stated aim is to keep drawdowns below 20 to 25%. A drawdown is how far a portfolio falls from its last high point.

How does the Papa Bear Portfolio work?#

Papa Bear trades at the close of the last trading day of each month.

  1. Score each of the thirteen funds below by the average of its 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month total returns.
  2. Hold the three with the highest score, a third each.
  3. Repeat next month, and reset to equal weights.

The thirteen funds are:

  • US large value (VTV) and large growth (VUG)
  • US small value (IJS) and small growth (IJT)
  • Developed-market stocks (EFA) and emerging-market stocks (VWO)
  • US real estate (VNQ), commodities (DBC), and gold (IAU)
  • Long-term Treasuries (TLT) and intermediate Treasuries (IEF)
  • Corporate bonds (LQD) and aggregate bonds (AGG)

Here is a made-up example. Gold’s four returns average out to the highest score.

TLT and IEF come next. All three of the top picks are defensive, so the portfolio sits in gold and Treasuries that month.

How does this version differ from the book?#

This version adds a 1-month return to the score, which picked the same funds on 86% of trading days since 2007. The returns are measured over 21, 63, 126, and 252 trading days.

The Muscular Portfolios site averages only the 3-, 6-, and 12-month returns (63, 126, and 252 trading days). A Tactfolio Rank scores by one reading. So this version adds the 1-month return and uses the 1/3/6/12-month average.

The site ranks on the close of the day before trading. Here the ranking and the trade share the month-end close.

Several funds stand in for Vanguard ETFs in the book that launched later. IJS, IJT, EFA, DBC, TLT, IEF, and LQD stand in for VIOV, VIOG, VEA, PDBC, EDV, VGIT, and VCLT. AGG stands in for the hedged international bond fund BNDX.

What the backtest shows#

Figures quoted in this article's text were measured on prices through September 25, 2026. The chart and tables are recomputed after every market close.

Over the ETF era, from early 2007, Papa Bear returned somewhat less than the S&P 500. Its worst drawdown was about 22% against the S&P 500’s 55%.

It beat the S&P 500 on risk-adjusted return, which is the return for each unit of risk. But it trailed a plain 60/40 portfolio.

Its best years were crisis years. In 2008 it gained about 6% while the S&P 500 lost 37%. It moved from commodities and gold into Treasuries as the year went on.

In 2020 it gained 25%. It held Treasuries and gold through the crash and growth stocks afterward. It also lost less than the S&P 500 in 2022.

In calm, rising markets it lagged. It trailed the S&P 500 by 19 to 24 percentage points in 2019 and 2023.

Its worst drawdown ran from January 2015 to January 2016. In that choppy year the ranking switched between bonds, real estate, and stocks and was caught out several times. It took until November 2017 to recover.

Since the book came out in early 2018 it has returned about 9% a year. That is the best of Livingston’s three portfolios over that stretch.

With simulated history the test starts in mid-2001 and returns about 11% a year. A gain in 2002 helped, a year when the S&P 500 fell 22%.

Treat these numbers as a hypothetical backtest. They show what the rules would have done on past prices after trading costs, not a track record. Our page on why past results mislead explains the gap.

When does Papa Bear struggle?#

Papa Bear struggles when leadership keeps rotating or when stocks and bonds fall together.

  • Rotating leadership. When one asset class after another rises briefly and then falls, the average-return score buys late and sells late.
  • Stock and bond losses together. With no cash fund, a year like 2022 leaves few places for the ranking to hide.
  • Strong US stock markets. It holds at most three funds, often not the S&P 500’s leaders.

How to try Papa Bear on Tactfolio#

The live strategy at the top of this page runs these rules with the stand-in funds and the 1/3/6/12-month score named here. It goes back to equal weights every month. Livingston only trims a holding that has drifted more than 20% from its target.

Copy it to compare with Faber’s GTAA Aggressive 3, which adds a trend filter. Or compare it with Mama Bear and the plain stock and bond Baby Bear.

Year by year

YearStrategySPY
2026*−1.7%7.9%
202523.2%17.7%
202412.6%24.9%
20237.4%26.2%
2022−13.9%−18.2%
202121.0%28.7%
202025.3%18.3%
20197.4%31.2%
2018−0.1%−4.6%
201712.9%21.7%
20166.2%12.0%
2015−10.3%1.2%
20147.2%13.5%
201324.4%32.3%
20127.4%16.0%
20111.1%1.9%
201012.2%15.1%
200912.3%26.4%
20086.1%−36.8%
2007*19.6%2.5%

* Partial year.

The rules as implemented

This is the exact tree Tactfolio runs monthly, rebalancing every run, with signals and trades at the close. Open it to inspect or copy it.

Livingston Papa Bear
RankTop 3 of 13
Score
Weighting
VTVVanguard Morningstar Value ETF
VUGVanguard Morningstar Growth ETF
IJSiShares S&P Small-Cap 600 Value ETF
IJTiShares S&P SmallCap 600 Growth ETF
EFAiShares MSCI EAFE ETF
VWOVanguard FTSE Emerging Markets ETF
VNQVanguard Real Estate ETF
DBCInvesco DB Commodity Index Tracking Fund
IAUiShares Gold Trust
TLTiShares 20 Year Treasury Bond ETF
IEFiShares 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETF
LQDiShares iBoxx $ Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETF
AGGiShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF

Make it yours

Copy Livingston Papa Bear and change one rule

Swap a fund, change a lookback or pick another rebalance day. Then compare your backtest with this one, and run your version on paper.

Needs Plus, $12 a month or save 25% paid yearly. Plus and Pro start with a 7-day free trial. 14-day money-back guarantee.

Sources and caveats

  • The site ranks on the average of the 3-, 6-, and 12-month total returns, over 63, 126, and 252 trading sessions. A Rank scores by one reading, so this version ranks by the average of the 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month returns over 21, 63, 126, and 252 sessions. The added 1-month return changed the holdings on about one trading day in seven from 2007 to 2026, and moved growth and the worst drawdown by under half a point.
  • The site ranks on the close of the day before trading; here the ranking and the trade share the month-end close.
  • Longer-lived funds stand in for the book's Vanguard ETFs: IJS and IJT for VIOV and VIOG (the same S&P SmallCap 600 value and growth indexes), EFA for VEA, DBC for PDBC, TLT for EDV (extended-duration Treasuries), IEF for VGIT, LQD for VCLT (long corporates), and AGG for BNDX (hedged international bonds; AGG tracked it more closely than unhedged BWX since 2013). VTV, VUG, VWO, VNQ, and IAU are the book's own.
  • Livingston says a holding need not be trimmed back to an equal share unless it drifts more than 20% from its target; this version restores equal weights every month.
  • Signals and trades use the close of the last trading day of each month, as in the source.

Common questions#

What is the Papa Bear Portfolio?#

It is the most diversified momentum portfolio in Brian Livingston’s Muscular Portfolios (2018). Each month it holds the three strongest of thirteen asset-class funds. It ranks them by an average of recent returns.

What ETFs does Papa Bear use?#

The book lists VTV, VUG, VIOV, VIOG, VEA, VWO, VNQ, PDBC, IAU, EDV, VGIT, VCLT, and BNDX. This version keeps VTV, VUG, VWO, VNQ, and IAU. It uses longer-lived funds for the rest, so the test can start in 2007.

How is Papa Bear different from Mama Bear?#

Papa Bear ranks thirteen funds on a blend of 3- to 12-month returns and has no cash fund. Mama Bear ranks nine funds on five-month returns and can move to cash.

Does Papa Bear still work?#

Since 2018 it has returned about 9% a year with a worst drawdown near 21%, within Livingston’s target. It has still trailed the S&P 500 in most strong years. The live record on Tactfolio shows how it is doing now.

Can I automate the Papa Bear Portfolio?#

Yes, copy the live strategy and run it in Trade, on a Tactfolio paper account or in your own Alpaca account (paper or live). Trade runs it on a daily schedule, but it only trades when the monthly ranking calls for a change. It is long only and holds US-listed ETFs. You pick the starting balance.

Keep exploring

Run it automatically

The funds it holds

How its funds compare

Learn the ideas behind it

Check the numbers