Black Friday: 50% off your first year of Plus or Pro, until Monday, November 30.See the prices

Beta Rotation Strategy (utilities vs. the market)

Charles Bilello and Michael Gayed's Beta Rotation Strategy. At the end of each week it compares utilities with the whole stock market over the past four weeks: if utilities did better, it holds the utilities sector for the next week; otherwise it holds the S&P 500.

Designed by Charles Bilello and Michael Gayed, 2014. Implemented and tracked by Tactfolio.

1×2×3×5×10×1999200320072011201520192023
Growth of $1, log scale. Strategy SPY. Hypothetical results on daily ETF prices with trading costs, through Nov 2026.
Jan 1999 to Nov 2026StrategySPY
Annual return (CAGR)6.8%8.5%
Worst drawdown−51.9%−55.2%
Sharpe ratio0.450.52
Volatility18.4%19.2%
Annual return since publication (Apr 2014)8.2%13.2%

The Beta Rotation Strategy (BRS) is Charles Bilello and Michael Gayed’s weekly switch between utility stocks and the whole stock market. Their paper, “An Intermarket Approach to Beta Rotation: The Strategy, Signal and Power of Utilities”, won the 2014 Charles H. Dow Award. Each week it holds utilities if they did better than the market over the past four weeks, and the market if not.

Key points#

  • The Beta Rotation Strategy is always fully in stocks. Only the kind of stocks changes.
  • It holds utilities when they have led the S&P 500 over the last four weeks.
  • Since early 1999 it returned about 7% a year, against about 9% for the S&P 500.
  • Its worst drop was about 52%, nearly as deep as the market’s, because utilities fell hard in 2008 too.
  • It lags badly when growth stocks lead, as in 2020 and 2023.

What is the Beta Rotation Strategy?#

The Beta Rotation Strategy uses the strength of utility stocks as a warning light for the wider market. Utilities are companies that sell power, gas and water. They are a defensive, bond-like corner of the stock market.

Beta measures how much a stock tends to move when the whole market moves. Utilities have a low beta, so they usually swing less than the market. Market technicians have long watched them as a leading indicator, a sign that tends to move before the rest.

Why do utilities lead the market?#

Utilities tend to do better than the market before it weakens. That happens when investors grow cautious, or when interest rates start to fall ahead of a slowdown.

Bilello and Gayed turned that idea into a rotation. When utilities lead, the strategy moves into them. It trades some upside for a lower-beta, steadier holding. When utilities lag, risk appetite is healthy, and the strategy holds the market.

How does the Beta Rotation Strategy work?#

At the close of the last trading day of each week, the strategy compares two funds and holds the winner.

  1. Compare the total return of the utilities sector (XLU) with that of the S&P 500 (SPY) over the last 20 trading days, about four weeks.
  2. If XLU returned more, hold XLU for the next week.
  3. Otherwise, hold SPY.

A rising ratio of utilities to the market is the same thing as utilities returning more than the market. So this matches the paper’s price-ratio test.

Here is a made-up example. Over the last 20 trading days, XLU rose 3% and SPY rose 1%. Utilities led, so you hold XLU next week. If SPY had risen 4% instead, you would hold SPY.

What the backtest shows#

Figures quoted in this article's text were measured on prices through September 25, 2026. The chart and tables are recomputed after every market close.

With real prices the test starts in early 1999, when the sector ETFs launched. Since then the strategy returned about 7% a year, against about 9% for the S&P 500 and 8% for a 60/40 portfolio. It trailed both on risk-adjusted return, meaning return for each unit of risk.

Its worst drawdown was about 52%, from December 2007 to March 2009. A drawdown is how far a portfolio falls from its last high point. It was nearly as deep as the market’s, because utilities fell hard in that crash too. It recovered in May 2011.

It had good years when defensive stocks led. It lost 1% in 2000 while the S&P 500 lost 10%. It did better than the market by about 11 percentage points in 2005 and 8 in 2007.

It lagged badly when growth stocks led. It gained 1% in 2020 against 18% for the market, and lost 2% in 2023 while the market gained 26%.

Since the paper appeared in 2014 it has returned about 8% a year. That came with a slightly better risk-adjusted return than over the whole period and a worst drawdown of about 39%.

With simulated history, built from utilities sector returns, the test starts in 1926, close to the paper’s own sample. Over that span it returned about 10.8% a year, just ahead of the S&P 500’s 10.4%, with a slightly better risk-adjusted return.

That is a much smaller edge than the paper reported. The difference may come partly from the S&P 500 standing in for the paper’s total-market index. It may also come from measuring four weeks as 20 trading days. The worst simulated drawdown, 86% from 1929 to 1932, was about as deep as the market’s.

Every number above is a hypothetical backtest run on past prices, after trading costs. It is not a track record. Our guide on how to read a backtest explains what these figures can tell you.

When does the Beta Rotation Strategy struggle?#

The Beta Rotation Strategy struggles when growth stocks lead and when a crash hits every kind of stock.

  • Markets led by growth stocks. When technology and other high-beta stocks drive the market, utilities lag. The strategy often sits in the market at best, or in utilities at the wrong time.
  • Crashes that hit everything. Utilities are still stocks. In 2008 the strategy lost 36%, about as much as the market.
  • Frequent switching. A four-week signal checked weekly can change its mind often, and each switch has a cost.

How to try the Beta Rotation Strategy on Tactfolio#

The live strategy at the top of this page runs the rule each week on XLU and SPY. Copy it to try a total-market fund such as VTI, a different lookback, or Treasuries instead of utilities as the defensive side. Treasuries are bonds issued by the US government.

The same authors also wrote the 200-day moving average study and Tactical Risk Rotation, which switches between stocks and Treasuries. You can compare all three side by side.

Year by year

YearStrategySPY
2026*17.8%7.9%
202514.1%17.7%
202431.3%24.9%
2023−1.5%26.2%
2022−22.8%−18.2%
202119.7%28.7%
20201.0%18.3%
201930.8%31.2%
20180.3%−4.6%
201720.6%21.7%
20161.5%12.0%
2015−4.4%1.2%
20148.0%13.5%
201328.2%32.3%
201216.3%16.0%
20115.1%1.9%
201013.9%15.1%
200932.1%26.4%
2008−36.0%−36.8%
200713.5%5.1%
200615.8%15.8%
200516.1%4.8%
200413.7%10.7%
200326.4%28.2%
2002−25.5%−21.6%
2001−14.3%−11.8%
2000−1.1%−9.7%
1999*10.2%21.1%

* Partial year.

The rules as implemented

This is the exact tree Tactfolio runs weekly, rebalancing every run, with signals and trades at the close. Open it to inspect or copy it.

Beta Rotation Strategy
IfAll of
Then
XLUState Street Utilities Select Sector SPDR ETF
Else
SPYState Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

Make it yours

Copy Beta Rotation Strategy and change one rule

Swap a fund, change a lookback or pick another rebalance day. Then compare your backtest with this one, and run your version on paper.

Needs Plus, $12 a month or save 25% paid yearly. Plus and Pro start with a 7-day free trial. 14-day money-back guarantee.

Sources and caveats

  • XLU and SPY stand in for the Fama/French utilities and total US market total return series. A rising utilities-to-market ratio over four weeks is tested as XLU's 20-session return beating SPY's.
  • Four weeks is taken as 20 sessions, so weeks with a holiday reach back one extra day.
  • Signals and trades use the close of the last trading day of each week, as in the source.

Common questions#

What is the Beta Rotation Strategy?#

It is Bilello and Gayed’s 2014 rule that switches each week between utility stocks and the broad market. It holds utilities when they have done better than the market over the past four weeks. Otherwise it holds the market.

Why do utilities predict stock market weakness?#

Utilities are defensive and sensitive to interest rates. They tend to do better when investors turn cautious or rates fall ahead of a slowdown. So their relative strength can show rising risk before the broad market reacts.

What ETFs does the Beta Rotation Strategy use?#

It uses XLU for the utilities sector and SPY for the market. The paper used long-run utilities and total-market index data.

Does the Beta Rotation Strategy still work?#

Since the paper appeared in 2014 it has returned about 8% a year. It trailed the S&P 500 in most calendar years, mostly because growth stocks led the market for long stretches. The live record on Tactfolio shows how it is doing now.

Can I automate the Beta Rotation Strategy?#

Yes. Copy the live strategy, then run it in Trade on a Tactfolio paper account or in your own Alpaca account, paper or live. Trade runs it on a daily schedule and only trades when the weekly check switches funds. It is long only, holds US-listed ETFs, and uses the starting balance you choose.

Keep exploring

Run it automatically

The funds it holds

How its funds compare

Learn the ideas behind it

Check the numbers