# Vigilant Asset Allocation (VAA)

> Keller and Keuning’s VAA-G4 uses breadth momentum to hold one of four assets or move to bonds. Rules, ETF backtest, yearly returns, and a live version.

Wouter Keller and JW Keuning's Vigilant Asset Allocation, four-asset version. When US, developed, and emerging stocks and US bonds all show positive weighted momentum, it holds the strongest of the four; if any one turns negative, it moves entirely to the strongest of corporate bonds, intermediate Treasuries, and short Treasuries.

Designed by Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, 2017. Implemented and tracked by Tactfolio; the live version is at https://tactfolio.com/s/tactfolio/keller-vaa-g4.

Vigilant Asset Allocation (VAA) is a monthly momentum strategy published in 2017 by Wouter Keller and JW Keuning. Its four-asset version, VAA-G4, holds one fund at a time: the strongest of US stocks, developed-market stocks, emerging-market stocks and US bonds. At the first sign of trouble in any of them, it moves entirely into bonds.

## Key points

- VAA-G4 always holds exactly one fund.
- If any of its four main funds has weak momentum, it switches to the best of three bond funds.
- Over the full ETF history it returned about 10% a year with a far smaller worst drawdown than the S&P 500.
- Since the paper came out in mid-2017 it has grown at well under half the S&P 500's rate.
- Its worst drawdown, about 21%, ran from January 2021 to March 2023.

## What is Vigilant Asset Allocation?

Vigilant Asset Allocation is a strategy that watches for trouble across all its assets at once. **Momentum** is the habit of prices that have been rising to keep rising for a while.

Most trend-following strategies check one asset at a time and ask if it is still going up. VAA asks a broader question: is anything in its universe going down?

Keller and Keuning call this **breadth momentum**. Their argument is that markets rarely crash all at once. When one major asset class starts falling, it is often an early warning for the rest.

So VAA-G4 is twitchy on purpose. A single asset with negative momentum is enough to take the whole portfolio defensive. That costs something in calm markets, but it is how the strategy tries to avoid the worst of a crash.

## How does VAA-G4 work?

VAA-G4 scores seven funds at the close of the last trading day of each month and picks one.

1. Measure the momentum of four "offensive" funds: SPY (US stocks), EFA (developed markets outside the US), EEM (emerging markets) and AGG (US aggregate bonds).
2. Momentum is Keller's 13612W score: a weighted average of the 1-, 3-, 6- and 12-month returns, with weights of 12, 4, 2 and 1. Each is measured between month-end closes, as in the paper. The most recent month counts the most.
3. If all four scores are positive, hold 100% of whichever of the four has the highest score.
4. If even one score is zero or negative, hold 100% of the strongest of three defensive funds. They are LQD (corporate bonds), IEF (7 to 10 year Treasuries) and SHY (1 to 3 year Treasuries).

That is the whole strategy. It always holds exactly one fund.

Here is a made-up example. At a month end, SPY, EFA and AGG have positive scores, but EEM's score is slightly negative.

One weak fund is enough. So VAA-G4 holds whichever of LQD, IEF and SHY scores highest, even though SPY looks strong.

## What the backtest shows

Figures quoted here were measured on prices through 2026-09-25. The chart and tables at https://tactfolio.com/strategies/vigilant-asset-allocation are recomputed after every market close.

The table above covers the full history of these ETFs. Over that span VAA-G4 beat the S&P 500 on risk-adjusted return, which is the return for each unit of risk.

It also had a far smaller worst drawdown. A **drawdown** is how far a portfolio falls from its last high point.

It returned more than a monthly-rebalanced [60/40 mix](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/60-40-portfolio.md), about 10% a year against 8%. But it trailed the 60/40 slightly on risk-adjusted return.

Its best stretch was the 2008 to 2009 crisis. It sat in bonds during most of 2008 and then caught the rebound in 2009.

The less flattering part comes after publication. Since the paper appeared in mid-2017, VAA-G4 has grown at well under half the S&P 500's rate.

Rising rates in 2022 hurt its bond fallback. It made little or nothing in strong stock years such as 2021, 2023 and 2024.

Its worst drawdown, about 21%, ran from January 2021 to March 2023. It did not regain that high until January 2026. That is why the "since publication" row in the table matters as much as the long-run numbers.

Like every result on this page, these come from a hypothetical backtest on past prices after trading costs, not a track record. Read [why past results mislead](https://tactfolio.com/docs/concepts/why-past-results-mislead.md) to see how a rule can look better in testing than in real life.

## When does VAA-G4 struggle?

- **V-shaped recoveries.** It often goes defensive near a bottom and comes back only after the rebound has started.
- **Years when bonds fall with stocks.** In 2022 its defensive funds lost money too.
- **Holding one fund.** One wrong pick decides the month.

## How to try Vigilant Asset Allocation on Tactfolio

The live strategy at the top of this page runs these exact rules at each month-end close. It reads momentum from month-end closes, as the paper does. You can open it to see every condition, copy it into your account and change it.

Try a different defensive set, or use VAA as one piece of a larger mix. The twelve-fund [VAA-G12](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/vigilant-asset-allocation-g12.md) steps into bonds more slowly. Keller's [Protective Asset Allocation](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/protective-asset-allocation.md) and [Defensive Asset Allocation](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/defensive-asset-allocation.md) use related breadth ideas.

## The rules as implemented

Runs monthly, rebalancing every run, with signals and trades at the close:

- Weight: Equal
  - If: All of: 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end) of SPY is above 0; 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end) of EFA is above 0; 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end) of EEM is above 0; 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end) of AGG is above 0
    - Then:
      - Weight: Equal
        - Rank: Top 1 · 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end)
          - **SPY**
          - **EFA**
          - **EEM**
          - **AGG**
    - Otherwise:
      - Weight: Equal
        - Rank: Top 1 · 1/3/6/12-month weighted momentum (month-end)
          - **LQD**
          - **IEF**
          - **SHY**

## Sources and caveats

- [Wouter Keller and JW Keuning, Breadth Momentum and Vigilant Asset Allocation (2017)](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3002624)
- [JW Keuning, Breadth Momentum and Vigilant Asset Allocation (TrendXplorer)](https://indexswingtrader.blogspot.com/2017/07/breadth-momentum-and-vigilant-asset.html)

- Uses the ETFs and 13612W momentum (weights 12, 4, 2, 1 on the 1-, 3-, 6-, and 12-month returns between month-end closes) from the source, with top 1 and breadth 1.
- Signals and trades use the close of the last trading day of each month, as in the source.

## Common questions

### What is Vigilant Asset Allocation?

It is a monthly momentum strategy by Wouter Keller and JW Keuning (2017). It holds the single strongest of four risky funds while all four have positive momentum. It switches to the strongest bond fund as soon as any one of them turns negative.

### What ETFs does VAA-G4 use?

The offensive funds are SPY, EFA, EEM and AGG. The defensive funds are LQD, IEF and SHY.

### How is 13612W momentum calculated?

It is a weighted average of the 1-, 3-, 6- and 12-month returns with weights 12, 4, 2 and 1. Each return runs from the latest month-end close back to the month-end close that many months earlier. This makes it react faster than a plain 12-month return.

### Does VAA still work?

It beat the S&P 500 on risk-adjusted return over the full ETF history, largely thanks to 2008. It slightly trailed a 60/40 portfolio on that measure. Since its 2017 publication it has trailed both the S&P 500 and a 60/40 portfolio. The live record on Tactfolio shows how it is doing now.

### Can I automate Vigilant Asset Allocation?

Yes. Copy the live strategy and run it in Trade, on a Tactfolio paper account or in your own Alpaca account, paper or live. Trade runs it on a daily schedule and only trades when the monthly pick changes. It is long only, holds US-listed ETFs, and trades the starting balance you choose.
