# Growth-Trend Timing with job growth

> Leave the S&P 500 only when jobs per worker fall and the trend breaks. Rules, backtest, yearly returns, and a live version.

The job growth version of Jesse Livermore's Growth-Trend Timing: hold the S&P 500 unless payrolls per member of the labor force are lower than a year earlier and the index is below its 10-month average at the same time, and hold Treasury bills then.

Designed by Jesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016. Implemented and tracked by Tactfolio; the live version is at https://tactfolio.com/s/tactfolio/livermore-growth-trend-timing-jobs.

The job growth version of Growth-Trend Timing is a stock timing rule that Jesse Livermore of the Philosophical Economics blog published in January 2016. It holds the S&P 500 unless jobs, measured against the size of the labor force, are lower than a year earlier. If the market is also below its 10-month average at the same time, it holds Treasury bills.

## Key points

- It holds the S&P 500 most of the time.
- It steps aside only when jobs per worker are down from a year ago and stocks are below their 10-month average.
- Since mid-2007 it returned about 12.3% a year, against 10.7% for the S&P 500.
- It lost 4% in 2008, when the S&P 500 lost 37%.
- Its worst drawdown, 34%, was the 2020 crash, which came before the jobs figures could fall.

## What is Growth-Trend Timing?

[Growth-Trend Timing](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing.md) obeys a trend-following rule only when the economy looks recessionary. That is when trend following has avoided the worst bear markets. The rest of the time it ignores the rule to skip whipsaws.

**Trend following** means holding an asset while its price is above its recent average and stepping aside when it falls below. A **whipsaw** is a sale followed soon by a buy back at a worse price. A **bear market** is a long, deep fall in prices.

## Why use jobs as the recession signal?

The author found that jobs, adjusted for the size of the labor force, make a good recession signal for this rule. Economists usually call employment a **lagging indicator**, a number that turns after the economy does. But the author found that lagging indicators can work well for this purpose.

To make it a more accurate recession signal, he divided payrolls by the size of the labor force. **Nonfarm payrolls** count the paid jobs in the US outside farm work.

The **labor force** is everyone who has a job or is looking for one. He treated a year-on-year fall as the warning.

## How does the job growth version work?

It runs once a month, at the close of the last trading day.

1. Divide US nonfarm payrolls (FRED series PAYEMS) by the civilian labor force (CLF16OV). Compare the result with a year earlier. FRED is the free economic data service of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
2. If it has not fallen, hold 100% S&P 500 (SPY).
3. If it has fallen, hold SPY while it is above its 10-month average, and Treasury bills (BIL) while it is below. The average is taken over the last ten month-end closes, the current one included, as in the source.

Both figures come from the monthly jobs report. Each counts from the day it was published, as it stood that day.

Here is a made-up example. Jobs per worker are a bit lower than a year ago, so the trend rule turns on.

SPY is still above its 10-month average, so you keep SPY. If SPY closes below the average at a later month end while jobs are still down, you move to BIL.

## What the backtest shows

Figures quoted here were measured on prices through 2026-09-25. The chart and tables at https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-jobs are recomputed after every market close.

The ETF-era test starts in mid-2007, when the Treasury bill fund begins. Since then it returned about 12.3% a year.

That compares with 10.7% for the S&P 500 and 8% for a [60/40 stock and bond mix](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/60-40-portfolio.md). Its risk-adjusted return beat both.

It lost 4% in 2008, when the S&P 500 lost 37%. It matched the market in most other years. The main exception was 2010, when it made 7% while the S&P 500 gained 15%.

A **drawdown** is how far a portfolio falls from its last high point. Its worst drawdown, 34%, was the COVID crash of February and March 2020.

That crash came before the jobs figures could fall. The loss was recovered by August 2020.

Since publication at the start of 2016 it has returned about 15% a year.

With [simulated fund history](https://tactfolio.com/docs/simulated-history.md), the test starts in 1960 and returns about 11.8% a year, against 10.6% for the S&P 500. It gained 4% in 1974, when stocks lost 26%, and lost 5% in 2002 against 22%. In 2001 it lost 5% against the market's 12%.

Strong as these numbers look, they come from a hypothetical backtest on past prices, after trading costs. A backtest is not a track record. Our note on [why past results mislead](https://tactfolio.com/docs/concepts/why-past-results-mislead.md) explains the limits.

## When does the job growth version struggle?

It struggles when jobs data turns late, in sudden crashes, and early in recoveries.

- **Late signals.** Employment turns only once a recession is under way. So the start of a bear market can pass before the trend rule switches on.
- **Sudden crashes.** A crash as fast as 2020's is over before the monthly jobs figures change.
- **Recoveries.** Payrolls keep falling after the market has turned, and the strategy waits for the price trend. So it can miss part of a rebound.

## How to try the job growth version on Tactfolio

The live strategy at the top of this page divides payrolls by the labor force with first-release FRED data, as the source does. First-release means each number as it was first published, before later changes.

Copy it to try a different trend length. You can also compare it with the [unemployment version](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-unemployment.md), which reads the same jobs report through the unemployment rate, or the [housing and income version](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-housing.md).

## The rules as implemented

Runs monthly, rebalancing every run, with signals and trades at the close:

- Weight: Equal
  - If: All of: 12-month growth of US nonfarm payrolls per US civilian labor force is below 0; current price of SPY is below 10-month moving average of month-end closes of SPY
    - Then:
      - Weight: Equal
        - **BIL**
    - Otherwise:
      - Weight: Equal
        - **SPY**

## Sources and caveats

- [Jesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), Growth and Trend: A Simple, Powerful Technique for Timing the Stock Market (2016)](https://www.philosophicaleconomics.com/2016/01/gtt/)

- Job growth is nonfarm payrolls (FRED PAYEMS) divided by the civilian labor force (CLF16OV), compared with a year earlier, as in the source's FRED chart; a fall turns the trend rule on.
- As in the source, the trend test compares the month-end close with the average of the last ten month-end closes, the current one included.
- Each economic figure counts only from the day it was published, read as it stood that day with later revisions only once released: at a month end the latest figure is the previous month's, the one-month lag the source describes.
- SPY and BIL stand in for the source's S&P 500 total return index and 3-month Treasury bills.
- Signals and trades use the close of the last trading day of each month, as in the source.

## Common questions

### What is the job growth version of Growth-Trend Timing?

It is a variant of the Philosophical Economics timing rule. Its recession signal is a year-on-year fall in employment relative to the labor force. It leaves the S&P 500 only when the market is also below its 10-month average.

### Why divide payrolls by the labor force?

The number of jobs grows with the population. Dividing by the labor force measures whether employment is keeping up with it. The author found that a more accurate recession signal.

### How is it different from the unemployment version?

Both come from the monthly jobs report. This one follows payroll growth relative to the labor force. The unemployment version compares the unemployment rate with its 12-month average.

### Does it still work?

Since publication in 2016 it has returned about 15% a year. The live record on Tactfolio shows how it is doing now.

### Can I automate the job growth version?

Yes. Copy the live strategy and run it in Trade, either on a Tactfolio paper account or in your own Alpaca account (paper or live). Trade runs it on a daily schedule, and it only trades when its monthly rule calls for a change. It is long only, holds US-listed ETFs, and you choose the starting balance.
