# Growth-Trend Timing with housing starts and income

> Leave the S&P 500 only when housing starts or real income weaken and the trend breaks. Rules, backtest, and a live version.

The housing and income version of Jesse Livermore's Growth-Trend Timing: when housing starts per member of the labor force fall more than 10% in a year, or real personal income grows less than 3%, the S&P 500 is held only while above its 10-month average, and Treasury bills otherwise.

Designed by Jesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), 2016. Implemented and tracked by Tactfolio; the live version is at https://tactfolio.com/s/tactfolio/livermore-growth-trend-timing-housing.

The housing and income version of Growth-Trend Timing is a stock timing rule that Jesse Livermore of the Philosophical Economics blog published in January 2016. It watches housing starts, which turn early but jump around, and real personal income, which moves slowly. If either looks recessionary, it holds the S&P 500 only while it is above its 10-month average, and Treasury bills otherwise.

## Key points

- It holds the S&P 500 unless housing or income gives a recession warning.
- During a warning, it holds stocks only while they are above their 10-month average.
- The warnings are a fall of more than 10% in housing starts per worker, or real income growth below 3%.
- Since mid-2007 it returned about 8.4% a year, against 10.7% for the S&P 500.
- Its worst drawdown, 25%, ran from January 2022 to March 2023.

## What is Growth-Trend Timing?

[Growth-Trend Timing](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing.md) is a rule that follows a price trend only when the economy looks like it is entering a recession. Otherwise it stays invested. The author tested several measures of the economy for that switch.

**Trend following** means holding an asset while its price is above its recent average and stepping aside when it falls below. A **recession** is a broad, lasting slump in the economy.

## Which economic signals does the housing version watch?

The housing version watches housing starts for an early warning and real income for a steady one. **Housing starts** count the new homes builders began in a month. They are a **leading indicator**, a number that tends to turn before the economy does: construction slows well before most recessions.

But housing starts are erratic. So he paired them with real personal income growth, which is steadier. **Real** means after inflation.

He set the breakpoints at a 10% fall in housing starts, measured against the size of the labor force, and 3% growth in real income. The **labor force** is everyone who has a job or is looking for one.

## How does the housing version work?

It runs once a month, at the close of the last trading day.

1. Divide housing starts (FRED series HOUST) by the civilian labor force (CLF16OV). Compare the result with a year earlier. FRED is the free economic data service of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
2. Compare real personal income (RPI) with a year earlier.
3. If housing starts per worker are down no more than 10% and real income is up at least 3%, hold 100% S&P 500 (SPY).
4. Otherwise, hold SPY while it is above its 10-month average, and Treasury bills (BIL) while it is below. The average is taken over the last ten month-end closes, the current one included, as in the source.

Each figure counts from the day it was published, as it stood that day. Personal income comes out about a month after the month it describes.

Here is a made-up example. Housing starts per worker are down a little from a year ago, so housing passes.

But real income grew less than 3%, so the trend rule turns on. If SPY is below its 10-month average at that month end, you hold BIL.

## What the backtest shows

Figures quoted here were measured on prices through 2026-09-25. The chart and tables at https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-housing are recomputed after every market close.

The ETF-era test starts in mid-2007, when the Treasury bill fund begins. Since then it returned about 8.4% a year. That is less than the S&P 500's 10.7% and a little more than the 8% of a [60/40 stock and bond mix](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/60-40-portfolio.md).

Its risk-adjusted return beat the S&P 500's but trailed the 60/40's. It gained 2% in 2008, when the S&P 500 lost 37%.

A **drawdown** is how far a portfolio falls from its last high point. Its worst drawdown, 25%, ran from January 2022 to March 2023, when the signals moved it in and out of a falling market.

It was recovered in July 2024. It lost 21% in 2022, against the S&P 500's 18%.

It lagged the market in these years:

| Year | This strategy | S&P 500 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 2010 | lost 2% | gained 15% |
| 2012 | 11% | 16% |
| 2016 | 5% | 12% |
| 2019 | 10% | 31% |
| 2023 | 9% | 26% |

Since publication at the start of 2016 it has returned about 9% a year.

With [simulated fund history](https://tactfolio.com/docs/simulated-history.md), the test starts in 1960 and returns about 10.1% a year. That compares with 10.7% for the S&P 500, with a better risk-adjusted return.

It gained 8% in 1974, when stocks lost 26%, and 19% in 1970 against 4%. It was whipsawed in 1990, losing 15% while the market lost 3%. A **whipsaw** is a sale followed soon by a buy back at a worse price.

All of these figures are from hypothetical backtests on past prices, after trading costs. They are not a track record. Read [how to read a backtest](https://tactfolio.com/docs/concepts/reading-a-backtest.md) for what to watch out for.

## When does the housing version struggle?

It struggles when housing gives false alarms, when income growth is slow, and in sudden crashes.

- **False alarms from housing.** Housing starts can fall sharply without a recession. That switches the trend rule on in a market that then recovers.
- **A high income bar.** Real income can grow less than 3% a year in slow expansions. So the trend rule can be on more often than in other versions.
- **Sudden crashes.** Monthly data cannot react to a crash as fast as 2020's.

## How to try the housing version on Tactfolio

The live strategy at the top of this page uses the source's breakpoints. It reads first-release FRED data for housing starts, the labor force, and real personal income. First-release means each number as it was first published, before later changes.

Copy it to change the breakpoints. You can also compare it with the [job growth version](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-jobs.md) and the [unemployment version](https://tactfolio.com/strategies/growth-trend-timing-unemployment.md).

## The rules as implemented

Runs monthly, rebalancing every run, with signals and trades at the close:

- Weight: Equal
  - If: current price of SPY is below 10-month moving average of month-end closes of SPY
    - Then:
      - Weight: Equal
        - If: Any of: 12-month growth of US housing starts per US civilian labor force is below -10; 12-month growth of US real personal income is below 3
          - Then:
            - Weight: Equal
              - **BIL**
          - Otherwise:
            - Weight: Equal
              - **SPY**
    - Otherwise:
      - Weight: Equal
        - **SPY**

## Sources and caveats

- [Jesse Livermore (Philosophical Economics), Growth and Trend: A Simple, Powerful Technique for Timing the Stock Market (2016)](https://www.philosophicaleconomics.com/2016/01/gtt/)

- The growth test uses the source's breakpoints: housing starts (FRED HOUST) divided by the civilian labor force (CLF16OV) down more than 10% from a year earlier, or real personal income (RPI) up less than 3%; either turns the trend rule on.
- As in the source, the trend test compares the month-end close with the average of the last ten month-end closes, the current one included.
- Each economic figure counts only from the day it was published, read as it stood that day with later revisions only once released: at a month end the latest figure is the previous month's, the one-month lag the source describes.
- SPY and BIL stand in for the source's S&P 500 total return index and 3-month Treasury bills.
- Signals and trades use the close of the last trading day of each month, as in the source.

## Common questions

### What is the housing and income version of Growth-Trend Timing?

It is a variant of the Philosophical Economics timing rule. It turns its trend rule on when housing starts per worker fall more than 10% in a year. It also turns it on when real personal income grows less than 3%.

### Why combine housing starts with income?

Housing starts give early warnings but are noisy. Real income is steady but slow. Using both lets the strategy react early without following every swing in construction.

### Why are the breakpoints 10% and 3%?

They are the recession breakpoints the author chose. Housing starts swing widely, so their bar is a large fall. Real income is steady, so its bar is growth below 3%.

### Does it still work?

Since publication in 2016 it has returned about 9% a year. The live record on Tactfolio shows how it is doing now.

### Can I automate the housing version of Growth-Trend Timing?

Yes. Copy the live strategy and run it in Trade, on a Tactfolio paper account or in your own Alpaca account, paper or live. Trade runs it on a daily schedule and only trades when the economic test or the trend rule calls for a change. It is long only, holds US-listed ETFs, and you set the starting balance.
